TASTE IT TUESDAY: PEANUT BUTTER SANDWICHES October 6, 2020October 6, 2020 by Clare Duffy Peanut butter and mayo; peanut butter and pickle; and peanut butter and cheese–also lovingly referred to as the “dog pill” sandwich. Clare was not excited for the “dog pill” sandwich. But after trying it…nope. It’s gross. Eric hates pickles, so he was least excited to try the peanut butter pickle sandwich. And it was his least favorite of the three.